Regulatory Library · USDA
7 CFR Part 3565: Section 538 Rule
7 CFR part 3565 is the rule behind Section 538, USDA's program of guarantees for rural rental housing, and the current text asks a lender to “demonstrate market and financial feasibility” without requiring a market study. A market study requirement exists only in a proposed rule, not a final one. Feasibility Study Company prepares independent market and feasibility studies for Section 538 lenders and sponsors, and this page quotes the sections that matter 12.
Section 3565.5(a)(4) asks for market and financial feasibility.
It is one of five threshold criteria every application must meet.
Section 3565.5(a) says applications from lenders “must include a loan request for a project that meets all of the following threshold criteria,” and paragraph (a)(4) is “Demonstrate market and financial feasibility; and” 1. The text does not say how to demonstrate it, who must prepare the demonstration or in what form. The Agency decides whether the demonstration is enough.
The rule is otherwise silent on market studies. In the codified part, the phrase “market study” does not appear, and “market and financial feasibility” appears once, at 3565.5(a)(4) 1. Lenders who say Section 538 “requires a market study” are describing practice or the proposed rule, not the regulation. Our Section 538 market study page covers how a study is scoped for these loans.
Section 3565.301 lists the market factors a lender must underwrite.
The market evidence sits inside the lender's underwriting factors.
Section 3565.301 says an approved lender “must originate and underwrite the loan and appraise the subject property in accordance with prudent lending practices and Agency criteria addressing the following factors” 1. Three of the eleven factors are the market facts a study measures: (b) “Property, vacancy, market vacancy or collection loss;” (d) “Tenant demand and housing supply;” and (k) “Estimated long-term marketability of the project” 1.
Those three are what a market study for a Section 538 property supplies. The rule also lists rent levels, debt coverage ratio and loan-to-value as separate factors, so a study that stops at demand leaves the lender to connect it to the credit factors.
The Agency can review preliminary feasibility, and the lender certifies cash flow.
Sections 3565.302 and 3565.303 set the review, its fee and the certification.
Section 3565.303(a) provides that “During the initial processing of a loan, the lender may request a preliminary feasibility review by the Agency when required loan documentation is submitted” 1. Section 3565.302(b)(1) names the matching Agency fee: a “Site assessment and market analysis or preliminary feasibility fee. A fee for review of an application for a determination of preliminary feasibility” 1.
Before a permanent guarantee issues, 3565.303(d)(2) calls for a cash flow certification in which “the lender certifies, in writing, the project's cash flow assumptions are still valid and depict compliance with the section 538 program's debt service coverage ratio requirement of at least” 1.15, “based on the lender's analysis of current market conditions and comparable properties in the project's market area” 1. The study's assumptions are the ones the lender later has to certify.
The guarantee and loan-to-value limits.
Maximums are in the rule, and the Agency may set lower ones.
| Item | Figure | Section |
|---|---|---|
| Maximum guarantee on a permanent loan | 90% unless the Agency announces a different percent by Federal Register notice | 3565.52(c)(1) 1 |
| Loan-to-value limit, nonprofit or government borrower | Lesser of 97% of development costs or the lender's determination of value | 3565.204(b)(1) 1 |
| Loan-to-value limit, for-profit borrower | Lesser of 90% of development costs or the lender's determination of value | 3565.204(b)(2) 1 |
| Debt service coverage ratio | At least 1.15 | 3565.303(d)(2) 1 |
Section 3565.204(b)(3) adds that the Agency may set lower loan-to-value limits “based upon its evaluation of the credit quality of the loan” 1. The lender's determination of value cannot exceed the appraised value, so the appraisal and the market study are checked against each other.
Section 3565.254(b) lists four third-party assessments and no market study.
This is the current list. It does not change until a final rule says so.
Section 3565.254(b), “Third party assessments,” provides that as part of the application “the lender must provide documentation of qualified third parties' assessments of the property's physical condition and any environmental conditions or hazards which may have a bearing on the market value of the property” 1. The assessments “must include” four items: an acceptable property appraisal; a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment; a Standard Flood Hazard Determination; and, for the purchase of an existing structure, rehabilitation or refinancing, a physical needs assessment 1. A market study is not among them.
A market study requirement has been proposed but is not final.
90 FR 27819 would add a fifth item to the third-party list for new construction.
A proposed rule from USDA, published June 30, 2025, would amend the regulation so that it “will require applicants (lenders) to submit a market study as part of the complete application” for the guaranteed rural rental housing program, and the change “will require all applicants to use a market study when demonstrating market need for new construction” 2. The proposed text of a new 3565.254(b)(5) reads: “In the case of new construction, a market study is required. The market study will be used to determine market feasibility. This is separate from the review outlined in Sec. 3565.303(a)” 2.
As of November 8, 2026 we found no final rule: the Federal Register search for 7 CFR 3565 since January 1, 2025 returned only the proposal, and eCFR shows the part last amended April 18, 2024 12. A study prepared now for a new construction project anticipates the proposal, but the current regulation does not require one. If USDA finalizes the proposal, this page will be updated to the final text, with its effective date.
Dates, amendments and last check.
The eCFR date, the last amendment, the proposal and the last check.
| Item | Date |
|---|---|
| eCFR up to date as of | |
| Part 3565, last amended | 1 |
| Sections 3565.52, 3565.204, 3565.254, 3565.301, 3565.303 | No change recorded since the eCFR history opens in December 2016 1 |
| Proposed market study rule (90 FR 27819) | Published June 30, 2025; not final as of November 8, 2026 2 |
| Last checked by Feasibility Study Company | November 8, 2026 |
Questions about the Section 538 rule.
Which provisions of part 3565 speak to market feasibility?
Section 3565.5(a)(4) sets the threshold criterion, “Demonstrate market and financial feasibility” 1. Section 3565.301 lists the market factors a lender underwrites, and 3565.303(d)(2) has the lender certify cash flow against current market conditions 1. The phrase “market study” does not appear in the codified part as of November 5, 2026 1.
Where does the proposed market study rule appear?
In 90 FR 27819, published June 30, 2025, which proposes adding paragraph (b)(5) to 3565.254 2. We found no final rule as of November 8, 2026. The Section 538 market study page sets out the proposal's wording.
What third-party reports must a lender provide today?
Under 3565.254(b), an acceptable property appraisal, a Phase I Environmental Site Assessment, a Standard Flood Hazard Determination and, for an existing structure, rehabilitation or refinancing, a physical needs assessment 1. No market study is on the list.
Can a lender ask the Agency for an early read on feasibility?
Yes. Section 3565.303(a) lets the lender request a preliminary feasibility review by the Agency during initial processing, and 3565.302(b)(1) provides for a fee for that review 1.
What debt service coverage does Section 538 require?
At least 1.15, which the lender certifies under 3565.303(d)(2) in the cash flow certification, using its analysis of present market conditions and comparable properties 1.
A Section 538 deal needs market evidence the Agency can test.
Feasibility Study Company prepares independent market and feasibility studies for guaranteed rural rental housing. Describe the property and we will show how a study answers 3565.5(a)(4) and the loan standards in 3565.301.
Request a methodology briefingPrimary texts and dates.
Two federal texts back this page: the eCFR, current through November 5, 2026, and a Federal Register proposal. Quotations were checked against stored copies on November 8, 2026, and the proposal is labeled as one.
- eCFR (Office of the Federal Register), 7 CFR Part 3565, Guaranteed Rural Rental Housing Program, up to date as of November 5, 2026; last amended April 18, 2024.
- Federal Register (USDA), Multifamily Housing Guaranteed Rural Rental Housing Program Requirement To Submit a Market Study (90 FR 27819, FR Doc 2025-10305), proposed rule, June 30, 2025; not final as of November 8, 2026.