Research Note · Housing Market Studies
State Housing Agency Market Area Rules: How 38 Agencies Set the Boundary
A market area drawn against an agency's rule can lose a housing credit application before its numbers are read, so the boundary decides what the borrower and the lender can rely on. Of 38 agencies, none sets a radius cap, six refuse a radius or rings, and only Texas caps the area's population 1234567.
State housing agency market area rules: the short answer.
Not one of the 38 state housing credit agencies covered here sets a numeric radius limit on the primary market area. Six of them, 15.8 percent, go the other way and refuse a radius, rings or circles as the way to draw it, and New Jersey asks for additional explanation when a boundary runs past three miles from an urban site or five miles from a rural one 1234568. The belief that a housing credit market area is a fixed radius comes from distances that belong to other tests: a two mile siting test in Alabama, a two mile distance (ten for rural properties) in Georgia’s competing property survey, and a five mile proximity report in Maryland 149. How to draw the boundary itself is the work of the framework method for market area definition; this note records what each agency requires of the result.
One agency caps size. Texas allows no more than 100,000 people in the market area, lets the excess stand only if it lies inside a single census tract, and builds the boundary from census tracts 7. Iowa sets a trigger, not a cap: a market area above 25,000 households needs the agency’s approval before the application is submitted 2. Five agencies require the boundary to be built from or listed by census tracts, and nine more name tracts among the ways it may be drawn. No agency defines the market area by drive time, and 7 of the 38, or 18.4 percent, print no market area rule at all 101112131415161718.
The secondary market area is required by three agencies, permitted or described by six, listed as a content item by three, and barred for calculating demand by North Carolina 3457192021222324252627. Demand from outside the boundary is fixed by one agency: Texas tells the analyst to assume an additional 10 percent of the market area’s potential demand 7. Arkansas bars households counted as leakage or spill-over for areas outside the market area 28. Five agencies, 13.2 percent of the 38, act on the boundary itself: Georgia calls its judgment the final determination of market area size, and Virginia may reject a study and disqualify the application over a market area it deems inappropriate 529.
The federal statute asks for a comprehensive market study of the housing needs of low-income individuals in the area to be served by the project, made before the credit allocation at the developer’s expense by a disinterested party that the agency has approved 30. It sets no rule for how that area is bounded, so each boundary rule below is the agency’s own choice, written into a plan, a guide or a rule that is revised every cycle. The edition behind each row matters, and the version of the NCHMA model standards each agency adopts differs (NCHMA is the National Council of Housing Market Analysts). The table below gives the rule agency by agency; the sections after it count the rules, take the radius, tract, secondary area and approval questions in turn, and say what each means for a study.
What the agency rules mean for the market area chapter you receive.
The market area part of a Feasibility Study Company study for a housing credit project states, before any demand figure, whose rule the boundary follows and which edition of that rule it read. A credit officer, an agency reviewer or a borrower can check five things in it against the agency’s own document.
The boundary as tracts and as a map. Illinois, Missouri, North Carolina, Tennessee and Texas require a tract basis, and nine more agencies name tracts as an allowed way to draw the area 23672022232427283132333435363738394041424344. The study lists the census tracts, shows them on a map with the subject site, and gives the area’s population and household count so the reader can see where the boundary sits against any size rule.
The written basis. Agencies ask for a rationale in different words: a detailed description of the method in Illinois, a methodology description in North Carolina, interviews with apartment managers in New Jersey, and an explanation for any unusual shape in Georgia 182732. The study states the barriers, the travel patterns and the competing properties that fixed each edge, so the reasoning can be tested rather than taken on trust.
A test of the boundary against this note. The study states whether the agency bars a radius, requires approval of a large area, bars or requires a secondary market area, or reviews the boundary before the study is finished. Where the agency has a clearance step, the study says when it was taken.
The demand base. Demand and capture figures are divided by households inside the boundary in the agencies that print that rule, and the study says which treatment of outside demand applies: none, a fixed share, or documented senior demand. The capture rate limits by state are the companion note; this one fixes the area those limits are measured over.
The edition. The study names the plan, guide or rule and its edition or effective date, because several of the documents tabulated here are older than the plan year they serve.
What 38 agencies’ documents say about the market area boundary.
The table gives each of the 38 jurisdictions one row. It reports what the document says about the basis of the boundary, a radius, a drive time, a population cap, the secondary market area, outside demand, the map, and who approves what. Each cell is a rule as the document prints it, shortened where it is long, and a cell reading “Not stated” means the document in the edition cited prints no rule on that point. That is a statement about the document and not about the agency, because a rule may sit in an application form, a funding notice, or a manual the plan incorporates by reference that is not among the documents cited.
Read the table by column as well as by row. The radius column shows that the question of a numeric cap has one answer everywhere. The basis column shows how little most documents say: many ask for a description or a rationale and leave the method to the analyst. The last two columns show where the agency reserves a step for itself.
| Jurisdiction | Basis of the boundary | Radius rule | Drive time | Population cap | Secondary market area | Leakage rule | Maps and approval | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | Market area must be clearly defined and supported; no method stated | No cap on the market area; separate 2 mile radius spacing rule against unplaced AHFA projects | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: not stated | 9 |
| Alaska | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: AHFC commissions the studies from pre-application materials; no boundary approval stated | 1011 |
| Arkansas | Tracts, jurisdictions, street names or other geography; tracts listed if PMA is not a whole city or county; rationale required | Not stated | Driving distance map of the suggested market area required (a map, not a PMA limit) | Not stated | Not stated | Households from categories identified as leakage or spill-over for areas outside the market area cannot be included; they belong in households projected to move into the market area | Map: required: a map which clearly delineates the market area; approval: analyst must be on the ADFA approved list; boundary approval not stated | 2831 |
| Connecticut | Boundaries defined with a detailed rationale from analyst interviews; zip code summary; tracts not specified | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Primary and secondary market areas both required to be defined and mapped | Demand assessed throughout the primary and secondary market areas; no separate leakage rule | Map: required: maps of both areas with zip code summary; approval: not stated | 19 |
| Delaware | Geographic, demographic and mobility factors; area supplying the majority (typically 60% to 90%) of likely residents | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: analyst approved by DSHA from its approved list; boundary approval not stated | 4546 |
| District of Columbia | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: study must adhere to the current NCHMA Model Content Standards; analyst accredited by NCHMA; boundary approval not stated | 12 |
| Florida | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: the study is by a disinterested party whom the Credit Underwriter approves; boundary approval not stated | 13 |
| Georgia | Narrative with rationale: political and natural boundaries, socioeconomic characteristics, comparable experience, perception of desirability; as homogeneous and proportioned as possible | A plain radius is not an accepted boundary; no cap (the 2 mile or 10 mile rural distance applies to the competing property survey) | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Senior demand may include residents from outside the market area if documented; gross demand from the primary market must be carefully defined | Map: required: PMA clearly outlined with the subject on a map; approval: DCA judgment is the final determination of market area size | 129 |
| Hawaii | Content item only: geographic definition and analysis of the market area; no method stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: not stated | 47 |
| Idaho | Geographic definition with description of the methodology used | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: required: map of the market area including the proposed site; approval: study from a provider on the Association’s approved market study provider’s list; boundary approval not stated | 48 |
| Illinois | Define the PMA with a methodology description and a list of all census tracts (FIPS codes) wholly or partly inside it; QAP defines PMA as the area drawing the majority of residents | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Capture rate assumes 100% of units filled from the PMA and counts households within the PMA only | Map: required: map of the primary market area denoting the subject and comps; approval: the Authority sets its own PMA (census tracts plus natural boundaries) for the preliminary project assessment; it need not match the study PMA; study PMA approval not stated | 3233 |
| Indiana | Tracts, jurisdictions, street names or other geography; narrative and map; county-wide or larger PMA needs specific justification | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Senior demand from outside the market area must be supported by market data on residents relocating from outside the PMA; analyst should not use an unsupportably large PMA to lower the capture rate | Map: required: map of the PMA including the subject site; approval: analyst must be on the IHCDA approved Market Study Analyst list; boundary approval not stated | 3435 |
| Iowa | Smallest geographic area from which the project competes to draw most of its residents; tracts, school districts, jurisdictions, streets or other geography | Radius PMAs not accepted; no cap | Not stated | PMA larger than 25,000 households needs IFA approval before application (a trigger, not a cap) | Not stated | Capture and penetration rates use only qualified households in the PMA; rent comparables must be in the PMA | Map: required: map of the PMA and a description; approval: IFA approval before submission for a PMA above 25,000 households | 236 |
| Kansas | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: study must meet NCHMA Model Content Standards Version 3 (adopted January 14, 2013) and the analyst must confirm it; boundary approval not stated | 14 |
| Kentucky | Local area from which the subject draws potential renters; tracts, school districts, jurisdictions, streets or other geography; defended with market data on commuting and migration | PMA and SMA boundaries based on radii are no longer acceptable; no cap | Not stated | Not stated | SMA required: a larger, more regional area around the PMA, mapped and defended | PMAs crossing state borders allowed only with convincing evidence of cross-border interaction | Map: required: map of the PMA and SMA with major features; approval: developers must select an analyst from KHC’s list of Approved Market Analysts; boundary approval not stated | 3 |
| Louisiana | Narrative must explicitly describe the factors that led to the market area designations | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Geographic definition of the primary and secondary market area is a content item | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: LHC orders the studies from approved disinterested market analysts; boundary approval not stated | 25 |
| Maine | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: QAP: study in accordance with the NCHMA Model Standards; guide: a qualified professional acceptable to MaineHousing must conduct the study, consistency with the standards is strongly encouraged and deviations must be explained by the analyst; boundary approval not stated | 1516 |
| Maryland | Geographic definition other than a simple radius, with maps | A simple radius is not enough; no cap (the 5 mile Multifamily Mapper report is a competing property search) | Not stated | Not stated | PMA and SMA both required in the definition and maps | Not stated | Map: required: maps of the PMA and SMA; approval: study consistent with the most recent NCHMA Model Content Standards; DHCD list of acceptable analysts; boundary approval not stated | 4 |
| Minnesota | Local area from which the project draws renters; tracts, school districts, jurisdictions, streets or other geographic information; composition and extent defended | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | SMA defined if applicable as the portion of the market area giving additional support beyond the PMA | PMAs crossing state borders allowed only with convincing evidence of cross-border interaction | Map: required: map showing borders and major features; approval: not stated | 20 |
| Mississippi | Area in which similar properties compete with the subject; factual basis for boundaries required | No cap; a five mile radius market area appears only as a worked example | Not stated | Not stated | Primary and secondary areas permitted with a valid basis; adjustments required for the secondary market | Secondary market demand must be adjusted for the decreased likelihood of attracting households | Map: required: map of the site and both primary and secondary areas; approval: MHC will fund only one development in each primary market area as the market study defines it, if at least one development has been funded within the previous two years | 21 |
| Missouri | Boundaries built from, or as a combination of, census tracts, with a narrative on how the PMA was determined | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Comparables must come from the PMA unless the analyst gives a very good reason; capture rate uses PMA households | Map: required: map or aerial photo showing the PMA, the subject tract and abutting tracts; approval: studies accepted only from firms approved by MHDC, and a study that does not substantially conform to MHDC’s standards is subject to rejection; boundary approval not stated | 37 |
| Montana | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: the plan defers market study content to separate MBOH requirements; boundary approval not stated | 17 |
| New Hampshire | Geographic definition with a description of the methodology used | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Primary and secondary market areas both listed in the definition item | Not stated | Map: required: map of the market area including the proposed site; approval: not stated | 26 |
| New Jersey | Comprehensive and reasonable rationale; example definitions: the competing area or the area supplying 60 to 70 percent of residents; apartment manager interviews on mobility | No cap; additional explanation required for boundaries beyond three miles (urban site) or five miles (rural site) | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: required: detailed neighborhood and market area maps; approval: not stated | 8 |
| New Mexico | Tracts, jurisdictions, street names or other geography; narrative on how the market area was determined | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | NCHMA text in the NM package: identify an extended or secondary market area if the subject could attract residents from a larger area | NCHMA text in the NM package: explain why the subject could attract renters from outside the defined PMA; capture rate uses PMA households | Map: required: map of the PMA including the subject site; approval: study must follow the Market Study Parameters; boundary approval not stated | 22383940 |
| New York | Municipalities, census tracts or block groups, streets or other features; clear explanation of the basis; whole tracts or block groups strongly encouraged | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | SMA described if one has been defined; not used in capture rates | Demand for the proposed units must come from within the PMA; SMA not considered in capture rates | Map: required: map that clearly delineates the PMA; approval: analyst must be pre-qualified by HCR; boundary approval not stated | 23 |
| North Carolina | Map clearly depicting the census tracts that make up the PMA; conservative, market supported delineation with local interviews and a methodology description | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Secondary market areas are not permitted for calculating demand | No secondary area demand allowed | Map: required: map depicting the census tracts in the PMA; approval: analyst submits a proposed PMA to the Agency for review before the study is complete; analysts may not discuss delineations with applicants until the study is complete | 27 |
| North Dakota | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: study by a disinterested party acceptable to the Agency; boundary approval not stated | 18 |
| Oklahoma | Map delineating the PMA; the PMA should be realistic and not too large | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Capture rate base is households in the PMA | Map: required: map delineating the PMA; approval: not stated | 49 |
| Oregon | Define the PMA and boundaries with the reasoning; no radius, tract or population limit | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: required: map of the Primary Market Area with the project; approval: selected projects must use approved OHCS Market Analysts; boundary approval not stated | 50 |
| Puerto Rico | Geographic definition with a description of the methodology used | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Capture rate base is eligible households living within a reasonable distance from the project site; no number given | Map: required: map of the market area including the proposed site; approval: not stated | 51 |
| Rhode Island | Content item only: determination of market area | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: RIHousing commissions the study from a disinterested party; boundary approval not stated | 5253 |
| Texas | Limited area drawing most of the demand; boundaries based on U.S. census tracts; only one PMA definition; size and shape reflect employment centers, services and amenities | Not stated | 20 minute drive time used in a feasibility occupancy test and drive time estimates in a proximity table; not a PMA boundary rule | No more than 100,000 people; may be exceeded if the excess lies within a single census tract | Extended Sub-Market Area analysis by the Underwriter where PMAs overlap | External demand fixed at an additional 10% of PMA potential demand; supportive housing demand may use data beyond the PMA but within the applicant historical service area | Map: required: scaled distance map with 11-digit tract numbers, subject and comparables, and total square miles; approval: Underwriter may require a combined PMA run from the combined census tracts | 74142 |
| Tennessee | Methodology description; list of all census tracts by FIPS code; PMA shapefile as one polygon plus a CSV of tracts | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Demand measured in the primary market area | Map: required: PMA shapefile illustrating the boundaries; approval: THDA will not accept a study by an analyst or firm not listed in its Approved Market Study Listing; boundary approval not stated | 4344 |
| Vermont | Analyst uses experience to define the PMA; tracts, jurisdictions, streets or other geography; map and explanation of the basis | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | SMA if applicable; VHFA expects it used infrequently; defined as the portion of the market area giving additional support beyond the PMA | If an SMA is used, the analyst must ensure household counts are not duplicated with projected in-migration into the PMA | Map: required: map that clearly delineates the PMA and SMA; approval: VHFA staff must approve the analyst; PMA approval not stated | 24 |
| Virginia | Analysts encouraged to be conservative; scattered sites must be inside the PMA | Concentric rings prohibited; no cap | Not stated | Not stated | Among the items the analyst must consider: Include secondary or tertiary markets (the text as printed carries no negation) | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: Virginia Housing may reject the study and analyst and disqualify the application for a PMA it deems inappropriate; only approved analysts may complete studies | 5 |
| Washington | Outline item only: delineation of market area | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: not stated; approval: analyst must be on the Commission approved list; deviations need written approval; boundary approval not stated | 54 |
| Wisconsin | Tracts, jurisdictions, street names or other geography; map, explanation and a list of tracts; defend in terms of the population served | Concentric circles not permitted; no cap | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Not stated | Map: required: map that clearly delineates the PMA; approval: market studies must be prepared by a WHEDA-approved provider; boundary approval not stated | 6 |
Source: agency documents named by the citations in each row, rules tabulated by Feasibility Study Company from the published text, retrieved November 9, 2026 1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354. A cell reading “Not stated” means the document in the edition cited prints no such rule.
Two patterns stand out. The documents differ most in what they ask the analyst to show and least in what they forbid: most ask for a rationale and a map, and only a handful forbid anything. And several cells that look like market area rules are not: Alabama’s two mile radius is a siting test for the application, Maryland’s five mile report is a proximity search, and Texas’s drive time sits in a feasibility test 4941.
How many of the 38 set what.
The counts below are counts of the rows in the main table, not estimates. They answer the plain questions an analyst or a lender asks first: does any agency cap the radius, does any define the area by drive time, how many require tracts, how many require a secondary area, how many fix outside demand. The shares are of 38, and each count lists its agencies so the reader can check it against the table.
| Rule | Agencies | Share of 38 | Which agencies | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A numeric radius cap on the market area | 0 | 0.0% | None of the 38 | |
| A distance past which more explanation is required | 1 | 2.6% | New Jersey | 8 |
| A radius, rings or circles barred as the basis | 6 | 15.8% | Georgia, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Virginia, Wisconsin | 1234562936 |
| A radius market area shown only as an example | 1 | 2.6% | Mississippi | 21 |
| Boundary built from or listed by census tracts (required) | 5 | 13.2% | Illinois, Missouri, North Carolina, Texas, Tennessee | 72732333741424344 |
| Census tracts named among the allowed ways to draw the boundary | 9 | 23.7% | Arkansas, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Minnesota, New Mexico, New York, Vermont, Wisconsin | 236202223242831343536383940 |
| Market area defined by drive time | 0 | 0.0% | None of the 38 | |
| A drive time used in a related test, not the boundary | 1 | 2.6% | Texas | 74142 |
| A population cap on the market area | 1 | 2.6% | Texas | 74142 |
| A size above which the agency must approve the boundary | 1 | 2.6% | Iowa | 236 |
| Secondary market area required | 3 | 7.9% | Connecticut, Kentucky, Maryland | 3419 |
| Secondary market area permitted or described when defined | 6 | 15.8% | Minnesota, Mississippi, New Mexico, New York, Texas, Vermont | 720212223243839404142 |
| Secondary market area listed in a content item with no rule | 3 | 7.9% | Louisiana, New Hampshire, Virginia | 52526 |
| Secondary market area barred for calculating demand | 1 | 2.6% | North Carolina | 27 |
| Households from outside the boundary excluded from demand or capture | 5 | 13.2% | Arkansas, Illinois, Iowa, New York, North Carolina | 223272831323336 |
| A fixed share for demand from outside the boundary | 1 | 2.6% | Texas | 74142 |
| Demand from outside the boundary allowed when documented | 3 | 7.9% | Georgia, Indiana, New Mexico | 122293435383940 |
| Secondary or in-migration demand adjusted or kept from double counting | 2 | 5.3% | Mississippi, Vermont | 2124 |
| Only a rule on market areas that cross a state line | 2 | 5.3% | Kentucky, Minnesota | 320 |
| Demand base stated as market area households, no outside rule | 4 | 10.5% | Missouri, Oklahoma, Puerto Rico, Tennessee | 3743444951 |
| A map of the market area required | 24 | 63.2% | Arkansas, Connecticut, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kentucky, Maryland, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, North Carolina, Oklahoma, Oregon, Puerto Rico, Texas, Tennessee, Vermont, Wisconsin | 123467819202122232426272829313233343536373839404142434448495051 |
| No market area definition rule printed | 7 | 18.4% | Alaska, District of Columbia, Florida, Kansas, Maine, Montana, North Dakota | 101112131415161718 |
| Agency reviews, approves, rejects or overrides the boundary or its size | 5 | 13.2% | Georgia, Iowa, North Carolina, Texas, Virginia | 12572729364142 |
Source: counts and shares worked out by Feasibility Study Company from the main table above and the 38 documents behind it, retrieved November 9, 2026 1234567891011121314151617181920212223242526272829313233343536373839404142434445464748495051525354. Texas: secondary copy of the rule.
Read from the other side, the counts show how much is left open. Against the 38, 29 agencies (76.3 percent) do not name census tracts as an optional basis, 32 (84.2 percent) do not bar a radius and 35 (92.1 percent) do not require a secondary market area. Twelve agencies require, permit or list a secondary area, so 26 (68.4 percent) do not, among them North Carolina, which bars it for demand 34571920212223242526273839404142. Against the 31 agencies that print some market area rule, 25 (80.6 percent) do not bar a radius, 28 (90.3 percent) do not require a secondary area, 29 (93.5 percent) print no rule adjusting for, or guarding against double counting of, secondary or in-migration demand, and 30 (96.8 percent) set no population cap 123456719212429364142. Of the 31, 18 (58.1 percent) state a demand base or a rule on outside demand; of those 18, 5 (27.8 percent) exclude households from outside the boundary from demand or capture and 13 (72.2 percent) do not 123719202122232427282931323334353637383940414243444951.
The seven agencies with no market area rule are not uniform. Five of them (71.4 percent) point outside their own text for the study: the District of Columbia, Kansas, Maine and North Dakota to the NCHMA standards, North Dakota also to a disinterested party acceptable to the Agency, and Florida to a disinterested party approved by its Credit Underwriter. The other two (28.6 percent), Alaska and Montana, commission the study or defer its content to a separate requirements document 10121314151718.
The zero rows are findings. No agency among the 38 sets a numeric radius cap or defines the market area by drive time, so a study that says a market area is limited to a set radius of five or ten miles repeats a rule that none of these documents contains. Only one agency sets a population cap. The rules that do exist cluster in three places: how the boundary is built (tracts, maps), what the area may include (a secondary area, outside demand) and who clears it. A map is required by 24 agencies, 63.2 percent; the other 14 do not print the requirement in the cited text 123467819202122232426272829313233343536373839404142434448495051.
The rules range from a bare content item to a long list. Hawaii, Rhode Island and Washington ask only that the study contain a market area item, while Texas prints at least seven separate requirements for the boundary, from a tract basis and a population limit to a scaled map with 11-digit tract numbers 7475254. A study written for one agency cannot be handed to another unchanged.
Radius and rings: no cap, six refusals and the distances that are not the market area.
No agency among the 38 prints a numeric radius cap on the primary market area. Six refuse a radius, rings or circles as the basis of the boundary, in these words.
| Jurisdiction | What the document says | Document and edition |
|---|---|---|
| Georgia | “Analysts may not simply use a radius” | 2025 Market Study Manual 1 |
| Iowa | “IFA will not accept radii primary market areas” | Appendix O, 2027 9% round 2 |
| Kentucky | “PMA and SMA boundaries based on radii are no longer acceptable” | Market Study Requirements, revised August 2022 3 |
| Maryland | “(other than a simple radius)”, written as a requirement for the definition of the market areas | 2026 Multifamily Rental Financing Program Guide 4 |
| Virginia | “Primary market areas are prohibited from being defined using concentric rings” | Market Study Guidelines, 2025 manual appendix 5 |
| Wisconsin | “The use of concentric circles as a Market Area is not permitted” | 2027-28 Appendix A, revised June 2026 6 |
Source: agency documents cited in the rows, retrieved November 9, 2026; quotations exact, some cut at the start or the end of the sentence 123456.
The refusals differ in strength. Iowa will not accept a radius market area, Virginia bars concentric rings, Wisconsin bars concentric circles, Kentucky says boundaries based on radii are no longer acceptable, Georgia says analysts may not “simply” use a radius, and Maryland asks for a definition “other than a simple radius” 123456. The Georgia and Maryland wording leaves room for a radius that is adjusted to follow barriers; the other four close the door on rings and circles outright.
The distances that are not the market area
Distances do appear in the documents, which is where the radius belief comes from. Each tests something else.
| Jurisdiction | Distance | What it tests | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Alabama | 2 miles | A siting test for the application (the 2-Mile Radius Requirement), shown in the market study; not a market area definition | 9 |
| Georgia | 2 miles, or 10 miles for Rural properties | The properties the manual names for the competing property survey, separate from the boundary of the market area | 1 |
| Maryland | Up to 5 miles | A proximity report from the agency’s Multifamily Mapper that identifies properties near the site | 4 |
| New Jersey | Beyond 3 miles (urban site) or 5 miles (rural site) | A boundary past that distance needs additional explanation; it is not a cap | 8 |
| Mississippi | A five mile radius | A worked example of a delineation for which economic data are not available, where county data may be used | 21 |
| Texas | 20 minute drive time | Stabilized affordable developments counted in the feasibility test; drive time estimates also go in a proximity table; neither defines the boundary | 741 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, tabulated by Feasibility Study Company, retrieved November 9, 2026 14892141.
New Jersey is the nearest thing to a distance rule for the boundary, and it is a trigger for explanation. A boundary beyond three miles of an urban site or five miles of a rural site needs additional explanation, and the plan separately asks for interviews with apartment managers to establish mobility patterns 8. A boundary that runs beyond three miles from an urban site is allowed in New Jersey; it carries a burden of explanation that a shorter one does not. Mississippi’s five mile radius appears in a worked example, where the point is that county data may stand in when economic data are not available for the radius, and the example does not set a rule for the boundary 21.
Georgia’s two mile and ten mile distances belong to the survey of competing properties and not to the boundary, and the same manual says the gravity model is appropriate in rural areas 1. Georgia’s manual also asks the analyst to describe the boundary with its rationale, taking into account political and natural boundaries, socioeconomic characteristics, the experience of comparable developments and the perceived desirability of renting in the proposed development, and it asks that the area be as homogeneous and proportioned as possible 1. Tennessee goes further, asking that the shapefile show the boundaries and depict the influence of natural and anthropogenic barriers 43.
Taken together the rules treat the market area as a product of competition, travel and barriers, and a circle as a shortcut. The failure that follows is catalogued in the taxonomy of review failures as F1a, a boundary taken from a radius or an administrative line when competition, travel and barriers define the real market; the agencies that bar a radius name it in their own words.
Census tracts, population size and what each agency means by primary.
What the documents mean by primary
The word primary does not mean one thing across the documents. Three use the same sentence, a geographic area from which a property is expected to draw the majority of its residents. The others define the area by competition, by where renters come from or by a share of residents, and the shares differ.
| Jurisdiction | What the document says | The test it sets | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Illinois | ““Primary Market Area” shall mean a geographic area from which the property is expected to draw the majority of its residents” | Majority of residents | 33 |
| New York | “The Primary Market Area (PMA) is the geographic area from which a property is expected to draw the majority of its residents” | Majority of residents | 23 |
| Vermont | “A geographic area from which a property is expected to draw the majority of its residents” | Majority of residents | 24 |
| Texas | “A limited geographic area from which the Development is expected to draw most of its demand” | Most of the demand | 7 |
| Iowa | “The PMA shall be the smallest geographic area from which the subject development will compete with similar properties to draw most of its residents” | Smallest area from which the project competes for most residents | 2 |
| Mississippi | “The market area is defined as the area in which similar properties compete with the subject property for tenants” | The competing area | 21 |
| Georgia | “Primary Market Area (PMA): the geographical area from which comparable properties and potential renters are expected to be drawn during the forecast period, including the income levels and rent- to- income ratio(s) assumed in the study” | Georgia ties the area to where competing properties and tenants are expected to come from | 1 |
| Kentucky | “For the purposes of KHC market studies, the Primary Market Area (PMA) is the local area from which the subject will draw potential renters” | Local area from which the subject draws renters | 3 |
| Minnesota | “For the purpose of market studies, the PMA is the local area from which the subject project will draw potential renters” | Local area from which the project draws renters | 20 |
| Delaware | “define the geographic area from which the majority (typically 60% to 90%) of potential residents of the proposed property are likely to move” | A share of likely residents, typically 60 to 90 percent | 45 |
| New Jersey | “the area immediately surrounding the project from which 60 to 70 percent of the residents are expected to be drawn”, given as one example beside the competing area | A share of residents, 60 to 70 percent, as an example | 8 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, retrieved November 9, 2026; quotations exact, some cut at the start or the end of the sentence 12378202123243345. Texas text: secondary copy.
Three different tests sit under one name. The majority-of-residents definitions test where residents come from, Texas’s “most of its demand” tests demand 7, and Mississippi’s competing area and Iowa’s smallest area from which the project competes test competition, so a boundary that passes one need not pass another. Only two documents attach a number to the share: Delaware says typically 60 to 90 percent of likely residents and New Jersey gives 60 to 70 percent as one of two examples 845. A boundary that draws 65 percent of expected residents (an assumed figure, for illustration) fits both, and it is also a majority under the Illinois, New York and Vermont definitions, but it says nothing about the competition tests or the Texas demand test. Beyond the majority in those definitions, no agency states as a rule which share makes an area primary.
Tract rules
Census tracts are the one geographic building block that several agencies treat as a requirement. Five require the boundary to be built from tracts or require a list of the tracts in it, and nine more name tracts among the permitted building blocks.
| Jurisdiction | Status | What the document says | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Illinois | Required | “a list of all census tracts (FIPS codes) wholly and/or partially within the boundaries of the PMA” | 32 |
| Missouri | Required | “the boundaries of the PMA must be a function of or agglomeration of census tracts” | 37 |
| North Carolina | Required | “a map of the PMA CLEARLY DEPICTING THE CENSUS TRACTS on the map that make up the PMA” | 27 |
| Tennessee | Required | “a list of all census tracts by Federal Information Processing Standards (FIPS) code which are within the boundaries of the PMA” | 43 |
| Texas | Required | “boundaries based on U.S. census tracts” | 7 |
| Arkansas | Named option | “by census tracts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography” | 28 |
| Indiana | Named option | “by census tracts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography” | 34 |
| Iowa | Named option | “by census tracts, school districts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography” | 2 |
| Kentucky | Named option | “by census tracts, school districts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography” | 3 |
| Minnesota | Named option | “by census tracts, school districts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geographic information” | 20 |
| New Mexico | Named option | “by census tracts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography” | 38 |
| New York | Named option | “by municipality(ies), census tracts/block groups, street/highway names, or other appropriate geographic features”, with entire tracts or block groups strongly encouraged | 23 |
| Vermont | Named option | “by Census Tracts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography” | 24 |
| Wisconsin | Named option | “by Census Tracts, jurisdictions, street names, or other geography”, with a list of the tracts that should be included | 6 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, tabulated by Feasibility Study Company, retrieved November 9, 2026 236720232427283234373843. Texas text: secondary copy.
Tracts make a boundary traceable: a boundary of whole tracts can be rebuilt from public census data by a reviewer who has never seen the site, which is the point of Missouri’s rule that boundaries be “a function of or agglomeration of census tracts” for verification 37. Texas asks for the tract identifiers in full, 11-digit numbers in numerical order with labels, and Tennessee asks for a list by Federal Information Processing Standards code and a shapefile with one polygon 743. New York goes a step further and strongly encourages entire tracts or block groups 23. Illinois asks for tracts “wholly and/or partially” within the boundary, so partial tracts are at least listed 32.
Population and size
Size is where the rules are scarcest. Texas states that the area’s base year population should be no larger than necessary to provide sufficient demand and no more than 100,000 people, and allows the figure to be exceeded if the amount over the limit is contained within a single census tract 7. Texas adds that the size and shape of the area should reflect proximity to employment centers, services and amenities, that a rural area should not include significantly larger and more populous areas unless the analyst substantiates that tenants would migrate from the larger cities, and that all of the analyst’s conclusions for the development must rest on only one market area definition 7. The Texas wording comes from the Legal Information Institute’s copy of the rule, a secondary source, and the Department’s own current rule governs.
Iowa’s 25,000 household figure is a trigger: a market area above it needs the agency’s approval before the application is submitted, and the same appendix defines the area as the smallest from which the project competes for most of its residents 2. Other agencies set no number and ask for justification at a point of their choosing. Indiana asks for a very specific description of why the market area is large when it is a whole county, several counties or a big city 34. Georgia requires a detailed explanation for larger areas or unusual shapes, Minnesota and Wisconsin ask the narrative to justify geographically large areas, Oklahoma asks that the area be “realistic and not too large”, and Virginia and North Carolina ask for a conservative delineation 156202749.
The reason for these rules is stated once in the documents, by Indiana: “the analyst should not use an unsupportably large PMA in order to achieve a lower capture rate” 34. A larger area adds households to the base and lowers any ratio divided by them, and Georgia’s plan lists an appropriate market area that does not overestimate demand among the factors indicative of market feasibility 29. This is the failure catalogued as Taxonomy F1b, a boundary drawn to fit the conclusion. The mirror failure is a boundary drawn small to hide competition, which agencies close from the other side by requiring comparable properties to come from inside the area, as Iowa and Missouri do 237.
The secondary market area and demand from outside the boundary.
The secondary market area
An agency can treat a secondary market area as a required part of the study, as a permitted extra, as a heading in a checklist, or as something to leave out of the demand figure. The documents split four ways.
| Jurisdiction | Position | What the document says | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Connecticut | Required | “primary and secondary market areas shall be defined and supported”, with maps of both | 19 |
| Kentucky | Required | The SMA is “a larger, more regional area surrounding the PMA”, and the analyst must “Specifically defend the PMA and SMA selections” | 3 |
| Maryland | Required | The definition of the market areas must cover the primary and the secondary area, with maps of both | 4 |
| Minnesota | Permitted | “Define the SMA, if applicable” | 20 |
| Mississippi | Permitted | A valid basis must be shown for the decision to include a secondary market, and adjustments are required for “the development’s decreased likelihood of attracting households from the secondary market area” | 21 |
| New Mexico | Permitted | In the NCHMA text the New Mexico package reproduces: identify an extended, or secondary, market area “If the subject could attract residents from a larger geographic area than the PMA” | 22 |
| New York | Permitted | “Provide the same information for the Secondary Market Area (SMA), if one has been defined”, but “The SMA should not be considered in the calculation of capture rates” | 23 |
| Texas | Described (Underwriter review) | Where market areas overlap, the Underwriter may perform “an extended Sub-Market Analysis considering the combined PMA's” | 7 |
| Vermont | Permitted | “VHFA expects to see SMA used infrequently” | 24 |
| Louisiana | Listed only | “Geographic definition and analysis of the primary and secondary market area” is a content item | 25 |
| New Hampshire | Listed only | The definition item covers “the primary and secondary market areas” | 26 |
| Virginia | Listed only | Among the items “the analyst must consider”, a list item reads “Include secondary or tertiary markets”; the text as printed carries no negation, so the current edition should be read | 5 |
| North Carolina | Barred for demand | “Secondary market areas are not permitted for purposes of calculating demand” | 27 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, tabulated by Feasibility Study Company, retrieved November 9, 2026 3457192021222324252627. Texas text: secondary copy.
Of the 13 agencies that address a secondary area at all, 3 (23.1 percent) require it, and 11 (84.6 percent) also require a map of the market area; Louisiana and Virginia are the two that do not 34571920212223242526273839404142. The three requirements are not alike. Connecticut asks for both areas to be defined, supported with a detailed rationale and mapped, and assesses market demand throughout both 19. Kentucky requires the analyst to defend both selections and treats secondary area trends as highly relevant to the primary area 3. Maryland requires both in the definition and the maps 4. The permissive group sets conditions. Mississippi requires a valid basis for including a secondary market and an adjustment for the decreased likelihood of attracting households from it, so households from the secondary area are added only after that downward adjustment 21. New York allows the area to be described and then keeps it out of the capture rate 23. Vermont expects the area to be used infrequently and asks how the analyst has avoided duplicating household counts with projected in-migration into the primary area 24. Overlap between neighbouring market areas, the Texas case, is handled by an extended sub-market analysis by the Underwriter, which is a review tool and not the analyst’s secondary area 7.
North Carolina bars a secondary area for calculating demand 27. That is the sharpest rule in the set, and it changes the work: a study written for another agency that adds secondary area households to the demand base will be wrong in North Carolina by construction. Virginia’s list prints “Include secondary or tertiary markets” with no negation in the text as tabulated, and a reader should check the current edition before relying on a reading either way 5.
Demand from outside the boundary
The rule on outside demand matters more than the rule on the secondary area, because it decides the base. The documents give eight different treatments.
| Jurisdiction | Treatment | What the document says | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arkansas | Excluded | The analyst cannot include households under the categories identified as leakage or spill-over for areas outside the market area; they belong in the households projected to move into it | 28 |
| Illinois | Excluded | The rate must be derived “assuming that 100% of the units will be filled by households within the Primary Market Area” | 32 |
| Iowa | Excluded | “The capture rate shall consider only qualified households in the PMA” | 2 |
| Missouri | Market area base | The overall rate is calculated over “age, size and income qualified renter households in the PMA” of the proposed development | 37 |
| New York | Excluded | “Demand for the proposed units must come from within the PMA” | 23 |
| North Carolina | Excluded | “Secondary market areas are not permitted for purposes of calculating demand” | 27 |
| Texas | Fixed share | “assume an additional 10% of Potential Demand from the PMA to represent demand coming from outside the PMA” | 7 |
| Georgia | Allowed if documented | For senior developments, demand “may include residents from outside the market area converting from homeownership and seniors living with and/or supported by their children” | 29 |
| Indiana | Allowed if documented | Information on seniors who will move from outside the market area “should be supported by market data” | 34 |
| New Mexico | Allowed if explained | In the NCHMA text the package reproduces: give “reasons for why the subject could attract renters from outside the defined PMA” | 22 |
| Mississippi | Adjusted | Adjustments must reflect “the development’s decreased likelihood of attracting households from the secondary market area” | 21 |
| Vermont | No double counting | If an SMA is used, the analyst must ensure household counts are not duplicated with projected in-migration into the PMA | 24 |
| Kentucky | Cross-state only | Market areas that cross state borders are allowed only with “convincing evidence” of cross-border interaction presented in the study | 3 |
| Minnesota | Cross-state only | Market areas that cross state borders are allowed only with “convincing evidence” of cross-border interaction presented in the study | 20 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, tabulated by Feasibility Study Company, retrieved November 9, 2026 2372021222324272829323437. Texas text: secondary copy.
The treatments do not net against each other. North Carolina bars secondary market areas for calculating demand, and Arkansas bars households counted as leakage or spill-over and sends them to the households projected to move into the market area, which is a separate line in its method 2728. Illinois goes furthest in the same direction: its rule derives the rate assuming that 100 percent of units are filled by households inside the area, so no outside household can help 32. Texas goes the other way and fixes the outside share at 10 percent of the market area’s potential demand, so the analyst does not have to estimate it, and allows supportive housing demand to use data beyond the area but within the applicant’s historical service area 7. Georgia and Indiana allow senior demand from outside the area when it is documented, and Indiana asks for market data from other facilities on the share of their residents who relocated from outside 2934.
Two cautions follow. A study that counts leakage or spill-over as demand in Arkansas has misread the rule, and a study in Texas has to use the stated 10 percent and no other share. Where a rule on outside demand sits beside a double counting warning, as in Vermont, the failure is catalogued as Taxonomy F2c, demand sources double counted 24.
Who decides the boundary: the analyst, the agency or both.
In most of the 38 the analyst draws the boundary and the agency approves the analyst. Sixteen agencies print an approval step for the analyst, through an approved list, a pre-qualification or an approval of the analyst by the agency or its underwriter, and none for the boundary: Arkansas, Delaware, Florida, Idaho, Indiana, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Missouri, New York, North Dakota, Oregon, Tennessee, Vermont, Washington and Wisconsin 34613161823243135374346485054. That is the federal baseline: the statute asks for a market study by a disinterested party who is approved by the agency, and nothing more about the boundary 30. In three places the agency commissions or orders the study itself. Alaska’s studies are commissioned from the pre-application materials, Louisiana orders its studies from approved disinterested market analysts, and Rhode Island’s come from a disinterested party commissioned by the agency 102553.
Five agencies go beyond approving the analyst and act on the boundary or its size, and Illinois draws its own area for one review.
| Jurisdiction | What the agency does | What the document says | Citations |
|---|---|---|---|
| Georgia | Final say on size | “DCA’s judgment will be the final determination as to the size of market areas or the adverse impact on existing properties” | 29 |
| Iowa | Approves large areas before application | “For proposed PMAs larger than 25,000 households, the market analyst is required to receive IFA approval prior to application submission” | 2 |
| Illinois | Sets its own area for the preliminary project assessment | “The Authority will determine a Primary Market Area (“PMA”) for each PPA for purposes of PPA review only”; the analyst’s own boundary is a separate matter | 33 |
| North Carolina | Reviews a proposed area before the study is finished | “Analysts must provide the Agency with a proposed Primary Market Area (PMA) for review as soon as possible but no later than February 20, 2026”, and “Analysts must not discuss PMA delineations with Applicants until the study is complete” | 27 |
| Texas | May require a combined area | “Underwriter may require Market Analyst to run a combined PMA including eligible demand and Relevant Supply from the combined census tracts” | 7 |
| Virginia | May reject the study and disqualify the application | “Primary market areas deemed to be inappropriate by Virginia Housing may cause the market study/analyst to be rejected and thereby cause the application to be disqualified” | 5 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, retrieved November 9, 2026; quotations exact, cut only at the end 257272933. Texas text: secondary copy.
Each acts at a different point. Iowa and North Carolina act before the application is filed or the study is finished, so the agency sees the boundary before it sees the findings. North Carolina’s sequence also sets a limit on the analyst: no discussion of the delineation with the applicant until the study is complete 27. Georgia and Texas act as reviewers: Georgia’s judgment on size is final, and the Texas Underwriter can order a combined market area built from the combined census tracts 729. Virginia acts at the end, and the consequence is the strongest in the set: the study, the analyst and the application may all be lost over a market area the agency deems inappropriate 5. Illinois sets its own area for its preliminary project assessment, uses an assemblage of census tracts containing the site and the adjacent tracts, and says the area is for that review only 33.
For the borrower the consequence is practical: where the agency approves a boundary, the analyst’s freedom ends at the agency’s door, and a study that arrives with an unapproved large area, a radius or a secondary area demand figure is exposed to rejection before its analysis is read. Why the boundary decides the conclusion more than any later input is the argument of the trade area is the study.
Outside the credit agencies: Section 538
The rules above govern housing credit applications. A rural rental project financed under the USDA Section 538 guaranteed loan program meets a federal rule instead, and the rule is thin on boundaries in the same way. Part 3565 makes it a threshold criterion to demonstrate market and financial feasibility, requires non-contiguous sites to be located in one market area, and has the lender certify cash flow on the basis of current market conditions and comparable properties in the project’s market area 55. The text of 7 CFR part 3565 contains no radius, census tract or population rule for that market area 55. A project that combines credit equity with a guaranteed loan has two readers and may need a boundary both accept; the study should say which rule it follows for each.
The NCHMA version each agency adopts.
Several agencies do not write a boundary rule of their own and adopt the model content standards published by NCHMA. What NCHMA says is stated here only as the agency documents quote or require it, and the version each agency adopts is not the same.
| Jurisdiction | What the document says | Citations |
|---|---|---|
| District of Columbia | “The market study must adhere to the current NCHMA Model Content Standards”; the analyst must be accredited by NCHMA | 12 |
| Georgia | Unless the manual states otherwise, “all processes and practices used by the analyst must conform to the National Council of Affordable Housing Market Analysts’ (NCAHMA) standards” | 1 |
| Iowa | The study must be prepared by a “National Council of Housing Market Analysts member unaffiliated with the developer” | 36 |
| Kansas | “Model Content Standards Version 3 (Adopted on January 14, 2013, by the National Council of Housing Market Analysts)”, which the analyst must confirm have been met | 14 |
| Maine | The plan asks for a study “in accordance with” the NCHMA model standards; the guide “strongly encourages” a study consistent with them and requires any deviation to be explained | 1516 |
| Maryland | “consistent with the most recent version of the NCHMA Model Content Standards for Rental Housing Market Studies” | 4 |
| New Jersey | The market analyst certifies that the study was conducted in accordance with the NCHMA Model Content Standards, “incorporated herein by reference, as amended and supplemented” | 8 |
| New Mexico | The package reproduces the NCHMA Model Content Standards marked “Version 3.1 Adopted September 2025”; the agency’s page requires a study that follows its Market Study Parameters, whose 2024 edition is “Based on Model Content Standards for Rental Housing Market Studies, Version 3.0” | 223840 |
| North Dakota | The study “must contain the National Council of Housing Market Analysts’ (NCHMA) current model content standards unless the Agency authorizes deviation from these standards” | 18 |
| Oklahoma | Attributes its capture rate definition to NCHMA and prints the council’s name as “National Council of Affordable Housing Market Analysts” | 49 |
| Rhode Island | Market studies “should be consistent with” the NCHMA Model Content Standards, “Version 3.0 Adopted January 14, 2013” | 52 |
| Tennessee | “The market study must be prepared in accordance with the most recent version of the Model Content Standards” | 43 |
| Virginia | Market studies for LIHTC developments “will model” NCHMA’s Model Content Standards, “Version 3.0” | 5 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, retrieved November 9, 2026; NCHMA’s text is reported only as they quote or require it 1458121415161822363840434952.
The documents adopt the standards in four different ways. The District of Columbia and North Dakota require the current standards, North Dakota unless the Agency authorizes a deviation, and Maryland and Tennessee require the most recent version, so the standard moves with each revision; New Jersey incorporates the standards as amended and supplemented, which does the same 48121843. Kansas fixes Version 3 as adopted on January 14, 2013 and asks the analyst to confirm it explicitly in the introduction letter or summary, which freezes the standard at a date, and Rhode Island and Virginia name Version 3.0 51452. Maine’s plan requires a market study prepared in accordance with the standards, while its rental loan program guide only strongly encourages consistency and requires any deviation to be explained in the analyst’s cover letter, so the plan makes the standard a requirement and the guide treats it as a default 1516. New Mexico’s package reproduces the model standards marked as Version 3.1, adopted September 2025, and that package is the document tabulated here that prints the version of the standards it reproduces 22.
Two points matter for the boundary. The NCHMA text in the New Mexico package asks the analyst to identify an extended, or secondary, market area when the subject could attract residents from a larger area, and to say when such an area is not definable 22. That is more permissive than North Carolina’s bar on secondary areas for demand and than New York’s exclusion from the capture rate, so an analyst who works from the NCHMA text alone may produce a secondary area that two agencies will not count. Oklahoma’s attribution of its capture rate definition to NCHMA prints the council’s name as the National Council of Affordable Housing Market Analysts, as Georgia’s manual and Mississippi’s plan also do, a reminder that an agency’s copy of a standard is the agency’s text 12149.
The 14 jurisdictions not tabulated, and the editions behind the rows that are.
This note covers 38 of the 52 jurisdictions made up of the 50 states, the District of Columbia and Puerto Rico. The 14 below are outside it, as are the possessions of the United States other than Puerto Rico, which the statute treats as states for the allocation of the credit 30. The title and every count in this note describe the 38 and make no claim about the others, whose current plans and market study guides should be read directly.
| Jurisdiction | Code | Jurisdiction | Code |
|---|---|---|---|
| Arizona | AZ | Ohio | OH |
| California | CA | Pennsylvania | PA |
| Colorado | CO | South Carolina | SC |
| Massachusetts | MA | South Dakota | SD |
| Michigan | MI | Utah | UT |
| Nebraska | NE | West Virginia | WV |
| Nevada | NV | Wyoming | WY |
The editions behind the rows
The table reports each agency’s document in the edition named in the references, and several of those editions are older than the plan year they serve or differ from a newer text in circulation. The documents that most need a check are below.
| Jurisdiction | Document tabulated | Edition |
|---|---|---|
| Arkansas | Market Study Guidelines | In effect from July 20, 2017 28 |
| Delaware | Market Study Requirements Checklist | Undated in the document 45 |
| Idaho | 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan | The redline copy; board action April 30, 2026 and Governor May 18, 2026 48 |
| Indiana | Market Study Requirements, Schedule C | The 2023-2024 plan edition; the 2026-2027 plan is a separate document 3435 |
| Kentucky | Market Study Requirements | Revised August 2022 3 |
| Oregon | OHCS LIHTC Market Analysis Guidelines | Web page that shows Last updated: 2022 50 |
| Rhode Island | Developers Handbook, Section 10, Exhibit 6 | Guidelines text updated September 2017, inside a 2026 handbook section 52 |
| Texas | 10 Tex. Admin. Code section 11.303 | The Legal Information Institute’s copy, effective January 2, 2025 by its history line 7 |
| Virginia | Market Study Guidelines, appendix to the Federal Housing Credit Manual | 2025 manual appendix 5 |
Source: documents cited in the rows, tabulated by Feasibility Study Company, retrieved November 9, 2026 357283445485052.
Three further points about currency. Plans change each cycle, and several agencies list a later plan or amendment than the one cited. A value of “Not stated” can become a rule when a plan points to a guide or manual that was not tabulated, as Montana’s plan defers to the Board’s separate market study requirements 17. The Texas rows come from the Legal Information Institute’s copies of three sections of the Texas Administrative Code, which are secondary sources, and the Department’s own current rule governs 74142.
What the agency rules mean for a housing credit market study.
The rules change what a study has to do in six ways. Each one ties to a review failure in the taxonomy of review failures.
Read the boundary rule before drawing the boundary. The rule may be found in Delaware’s checklist, Maryland’s program guide, New York’s manual, Texas’s administrative rule, or the web pages of Iowa and Oregon 247234550. A study that reads the plan and not the document carrying the rule has missed it. A boundary drawn first and checked afterward is exposed to Taxonomy F8a, a study that fails to give the reviewing authority the contents and format it requires.
Build the boundary from tracts and keep the list. Even where tracts are not required, a boundary of whole tracts is the one a reviewer can rebuild, and the agencies that ask for lists, shapefiles and 11-digit identifiers show what a reviewer will want 743. Draw the boundary from barriers, travel patterns and competing properties, and test it against where the comparable properties’ renters come from, which is the point of New Jersey’s interviews with apartment managers and North Carolina’s local interviews 827. A boundary that was never tested against the origin of renters is Taxonomy F1c.
Do not use a radius as the boundary and do not let a distance test stand for one. Six agencies bar it, and the other 32 have not written a number that would make it safe. A distance belongs where an agency puts it: the Alabama siting test, the Georgia survey, the Maryland proximity report and the New Jersey explanation trigger 1489.
Clear the boundary where the agency asks. North Carolina wants a proposed area before the study is finished, Iowa wants approval above 25,000 households before the application, Georgia’s judgment on size is final and Virginia may reject the study 252729. A study that reaches those agencies with an unreviewed boundary has put the application at risk before its numbers are read, and a study in Texas should be built on one definition only and sized against the 100,000 person limit 7. This is Taxonomy F1a and F1b in one: the agencies reject a boundary that fits the conclusion and one that was never defended.
Use the agency’s demand base, and say which one. The base changes with the agency: households inside the area only, as in Illinois, Iowa and New York; a fixed 10 percent more, as in Texas; documented senior demand from outside, as in Georgia and Indiana; and an adjusted secondary area, as in Mississippi 272123293234. The demand analysis that builds the base must follow the rule of the agency reading the study, and the capture rate that divides by the base is the subject of the companion note on capture rate limits. A study should never compare a ratio computed on one agency’s base with a limit written for another’s.
State the edition and the date. A rule tabulated from a 2017 guide or a 2022 page can have been replaced, and Taxonomy F8b, the wrong standard or edition, is the failure of a study that follows the text it found and not the text the agency applies 2850.
The evidence here is the agencies’ own documents, which say what they will not accept. They do not count how often studies fail, and this note makes no claim about prevalence.
State housing agency market area questions.
Which market area exhibits do housing credit agencies ask for in a study?
A map that shows the boundary and the subject site, and a written basis for the boundary. Twenty-four of the 38 agencies require a map by name. Illinois, Tennessee and Texas ask for a list of the census tracts, Tennessee for a shapefile, and Texas for a scaled map with 11-digit tract numbers and the area in square miles. Where an agency sets a size trigger, the boundary should be shown to sit inside it 273243.
Can the market area decision change whether an application is accepted?
In five of the 38 the agency acts on the boundary. Iowa requires approval of a market area above 25,000 households before the application is submitted, and North Carolina reviews a proposed area before the study is finished. Georgia's judgment on size is final, Texas lets the Underwriter require a combined area, and Virginia may reject the study and disqualify the application over an area it deems inappropriate 2572729. In Mississippi the boundary matters another way: MHC will fund only one development in each primary market area as the market study defines it, if at least one development has been funded within the previous two years 21.
Do states limit a LIHTC market area to a radius?
No. None of the 38 agencies sets a numeric radius cap. Six refuse a radius, rings or circles as the basis of the boundary, and New Jersey asks for additional explanation when a boundary passes three miles from an urban site or five from a rural one. Other distances in the documents, in Alabama, Georgia and Maryland, test something else 12345689.
Does any state cap the population of the market area?
Only Texas does. Its rule says no more than 100,000 people, and the figure may be exceeded if the amount over the limit lies within a single census tract. Iowa sets a different kind of rule, a trigger: a market area larger than 25,000 households needs the agency's approval before application 27.
Do housing agencies require a secondary market area?
Three of the 38 do: Connecticut, Kentucky and Maryland. Six more permit or describe one, three list it in a content item, and North Carolina bars it for calculating demand. New York describes one but keeps it out of capture rates, and Vermont expects it to be used infrequently 3419232427.
Can demand come from outside the primary market area?
It depends on the agency. Texas fixes outside demand at an additional 10 percent of the area's potential demand. Arkansas bars households counted as leakage or spill-over, and Illinois, Iowa, Missouri and New York base demand on households inside the area. Georgia and Indiana allow senior demand from outside when it is documented 27232829323437.
Does any state define the market area by drive time?
None of the 38 does. Texas uses a 20 minute drive time to count stabilized affordable developments in its feasibility test and asks for drive time estimates in a proximity table, but neither fixes the boundary. Arkansas asks for a driving distance map of the suggested market area, which is a map and not a limit 72841.
Need the market area drawn before the agency asks?
Name the agency and the plan year, and the boundary comes back as a tract list and map checked against that agency's rule, its size triggers and its demand base.
Request a methodology briefingNumbered references.
Agency plans, guides, checklists and rules come first, each where it states a market area rule. The date given with each entry is its edition or effective date, followed by the retrieval date.
- Georgia Department of Community Affairs, 2025 Market Study Manual, 2025 manual; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Iowa Finance Authority, Appendix O: Market Study Requirements, 2027 9% round, 2027 9% round; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Kentucky Housing Corporation, Market Study Requirements, Revised August 2022; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Maryland Department of Housing and Community Development, Community Development Administration, Multifamily Rental Financing Program Guide (attachment to the Qualified Allocation Plan), 2026 guide, effective April 8, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Virginia Housing, Federal Housing Credit Manual, Market Study Guidelines appendix, 2025 manual appendix; retrieved November 9, 2026. A 2025 manual appendix; read the current manual.
- Wisconsin Housing and Economic Development Authority, 2027-28 Qualified Allocation Plan, Appendix A: Market Study Guidelines, Revised June 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Cornell Legal Information Institute (copy of the Texas Administrative Code), 10 Tex. Admin. Code section 11.303, Market Analysis Rules and Guidelines, Effective January 2, 2025 by its history line; retrieved November 9, 2026. Secondary source: the Legal Information Institute's copy of the rule, not the agency's own publication; the Department's own current rule governs.
- New Jersey Housing and Mortgage Finance Agency, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan, N.J.A.C. 5:80-33, Adopted February 2, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Alabama Housing Finance Authority, 2027 Housing Credit Qualified Allocation Plan, Adopted June 10, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Alaska Housing Finance Corporation, GOAL program page, Web page, November 9, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Alaska Housing Finance Corporation, GOAL Program Rating and Award Criteria Plan (Qualified Allocation Plan), Version June 24, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- District of Columbia Department of Housing and Community Development, 2025 LIHTC Qualified Allocation Plan, Published December 9, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Florida Housing Finance Corporation, Rule 67-48.0072, Florida Administrative Code, Credit Underwriting and Loan Procedures, Effective August 13, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Kansas Housing Resources Corporation, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan, Adopted September 29, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- MaineHousing, 2025-2026 Qualified Allocation Plan, 2025-2026 plan; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- MaineHousing, Rental Loan Program Guide, Effective September 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Montana Board of Housing, 2027 Qualified Allocation Plan, Governor approved November 24, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- North Dakota Housing Finance Agency, 2027 Allocation Plan, Low Income Housing Tax Credit Program, 2027 plan; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Connecticut Housing Finance Authority, Appraisal and Market Study Guidelines, Rev. 09/2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Minnesota Housing, Housing Tax Credits Market Study Guidelines, Last updated October 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Mississippi Home Corporation, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan with Addendum F, Market Study Guide and Checklist, 2026 plan; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- National Council of Housing Market Analysts (as published in the New Mexico 2026 plan package), NCHMA Model Content Standards, as incorporated in the New Mexico 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan package, Version 3.1, adopted September 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026. Reproduced in the plan package; NCHMA's own current text should be consulted.
- New York State Homes and Community Renewal, Capital Programs Manual, Section 5.00 Development Requirements, Market Study Content Guidelines, 2026 edition, posted July 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Vermont Housing Finance Agency, Market Study Standards, Revised October 2024, effective January 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Louisiana Housing Corporation, 2025 Qualified Allocation Plan, as amended January 13, 2026, Amended January 13, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- New Hampshire Housing, Market Study Report Requirements, July 10, 2024; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- North Carolina Housing Finance Agency, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan, Appendix A: Market Study Standards and Requirements, 2026 plan cycle; retrieved November 9, 2026. Appendix A is linked from the agency's 2026 plan page.
- Arkansas Development Finance Authority, Market Study Guidelines, Effective July 20, 2017 for later submissions; retrieved November 9, 2026. The guide the agency posts; its effective date is 2017.
- Georgia Department of Community Affairs, 2026-2027 Qualified Allocation Plan (amended), Adopted August 24, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- U.S. Government Publishing Office (U.S. Code), 26 U.S.C. 42, Low-income housing credit, subsections (h)(8)(B) and (m)(1)(A)(iii), 2024 edition; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Arkansas Development Finance Authority, 2027 Qualified Allocation Plan, 2027 plan, posted September 1, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Illinois Housing Development Authority, Standards for Site and Market Study Reviews and Professionals, 2027-2028 Qualified Allocation Plan, 2027-2028 edition, posted July 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Illinois Housing Development Authority, 2027-2028 Qualified Allocation Plan, 2027-2028 plan, posted August 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Indiana Housing and Community Development Authority, Market Study Requirements, Schedule C, 2023-2024 plan edition; retrieved November 9, 2026. The edition for the 2023-2024 plan; read the current Schedule C.
- Indiana Housing and Community Development Authority, 2026-2027 Qualified Allocation Plan, Section 5.1(D) Market Study, 2026-2027 plan, final; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Iowa Finance Authority, 2026-2027 9% Qualified Allocation Plan, Section 2.5 Market Study, Approved by the Board August 6, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Missouri Housing Development Commission, 2026 Market Study Guidelines, Effective July 18, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- New Mexico Mortgage Finance Authority, Market Study Parameters, 2024 edition; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- New Mexico Mortgage Finance Authority, 9% Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Program Qualified Allocation Plan, 2026 plan, effective December 1, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- New Mexico Mortgage Finance Authority, Market Study Requirements (developer resources page), Web page, undated; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Cornell Legal Information Institute (copy of the Texas Administrative Code), 10 Tex. Admin. Code section 11.302, Underwriting Rules and Guidelines, subsection (i), Effective January 2, 2025 by its history line; retrieved November 9, 2026. Secondary source: the Legal Information Institute's copy of the rule, not the agency's own publication; the Department's own current rule governs.
- Cornell Legal Information Institute (copy of the Texas Administrative Code), 10 Tex. Admin. Code section 11.205, Required Third Party Reports, Effective January 2, 2025 by its history line; retrieved November 9, 2026. Secondary source: the Legal Information Institute's copy of the rule, not the agency's own publication; the Department's own current rule governs.
- Tennessee Housing Development Agency, Market Study Guidance, Last updated January 30, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Tennessee Housing Development Agency, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan, Governor approved December 17, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Delaware State Housing Authority, Market Study Requirements Checklist, Undated; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Delaware State Housing Authority, 2025-2026 LIHTC Qualified Allocation Plan, Final, updated January 7, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Hawaii Housing Finance and Development Corporation, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan (LIHTC), Effective for calendar year 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Idaho Housing and Finance Association, 2026 LIHTC Qualified Allocation Plan (redline copy), Board April 30, 2026; Governor May 18, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026. The posted file is the redline copy of the plan.
- Oklahoma Housing Finance Agency, Affordable Housing Tax Credits Program 2027 Application Instructions (Qualified Allocation Plan and Attachment B, Program Market Study Requirements), Effective January 1, 2027; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Oregon Housing and Community Services, LIHTC Market Analysis Guidelines, Web page, last updated 2022; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- Puerto Rico Housing Finance Authority, 2025 Qualified Allocation Plan, Low-Income Housing Tax Credit Program, Rev. October 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- RIHousing, 2026 Developers Handbook, Section 10, Statistical Data and Forms (Exhibit 6, Market Study Requirements), 2026 handbook; guideline text updated September 2017; retrieved November 9, 2026. The guidelines text inside the 2026 handbook is dated September 2017.
- RIHousing, 2026 Qualified Allocation Plan, Attachment C, 2026 plan; retrieved November 9, 2026. The posted file is titled as a proposed plan; read the final plan.
- Washington State Housing Finance Commission, 9% Competitive Housing Tax Credit Policies, Last approved July 25, 2024, republished August 1, 2025; retrieved November 9, 2026.
- U.S. Department of Agriculture, Rural Housing Service (eCFR, U.S. Government Publishing Office), 7 CFR part 3565, Guaranteed Rural Rental Housing Program, eCFR current as of November 5, 2026; retrieved November 9, 2026.